This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Moderators: Devon, Gorehound, Si, SickThings, Shoesalesman
-
- Billion Dollar Baby
- Posts: 251
- Joined: Sat Jun 25, 2005 4:18 am
- Location: Sydney
This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Whats the story with this ?
Does Alice sing vox on all the songs or just on Wish you were here ?
Details are very scant considering it's released next week
Just wondering if its worth buying
Does Alice sing vox on all the songs or just on Wish you were here ?
Details are very scant considering it's released next week
Just wondering if its worth buying
- suziginajackson
- Killer
- Posts: 204
- Joined: Tue Aug 07, 2007 5:23 pm
- Location: England
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
This is the track listing, according to Amazon:
Disc: 1
1. Wish You Were Here - Alice Cooper, Rick Wakeman
2. Tuning
3. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V
4. Welcome To The Machine
5. Have A Cigar
6. Wish You Were Here - Dave Fowler, Stephen McElroy
7. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts VI-IX
8. Eclipse
It seems that Alice is only featured on the one track
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASI ... ndamage-21
Disc: 1
1. Wish You Were Here - Alice Cooper, Rick Wakeman
2. Tuning
3. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V
4. Welcome To The Machine
5. Have A Cigar
6. Wish You Were Here - Dave Fowler, Stephen McElroy
7. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts VI-IX
8. Eclipse
It seems that Alice is only featured on the one track
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASI ... ndamage-21
People try to put us down
Just because we get around
Just because we get around
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
As this is my second favorite Floyd album (first is Animals) I will buy this.
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Alice sings on more than one song. You can hear welcome to the machine on the floyd fan site brain damage, it's Alice singing and they suggest he sings on shine on you crazy diamond too
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
It must be true A_Michael said so
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
DEFINITLY don`t get excited!Rob wrote: Don`t get excited
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
MG...terrible, just terrible...
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
ow..If people doubted the covers on HV, now this must be causing real earache..
Tried to listen to Welcome to the Machine....and stopped halfway..
I don't think Alice's voice suites this music..
Tried to listen to Welcome to the Machine....and stopped halfway..
I don't think Alice's voice suites this music..
you really wouldn't understand..
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Not available in this area. Perhaps just as well.
- SickThings
- Dada God
- Posts: 875
- Joined: Thu Jun 09, 2005 4:04 pm
- Location: Elizabethtown, KY
- Contact:
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
For me, the "symphonic" arrangement is even worse. Totally neuters the song.patrick wrote:ow..If people doubted the covers on HV, now this must be causing real earache..
Tried to listen to Welcome to the Machine....and stopped halfway..
I don't think Alice's voice suites this music..
Hunter
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
pitkin88 wrote:
Not available in this area. Perhaps just as well.
You're lucky--if it shows up in my area I just may have to move!
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Have A Cigar is on Spotify (as a single) but strangely is instrumental...
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Just when you thought it couldn't get any worse than 'Art Of McCartney' & 'Hollywood Vampires' - it does. Karaoke Alice, prog dinosaur RW, and 'slumming it' orchestra, 'interpret' perpetual dullards Pink Floyd. They're like musical zombies: forever condemned to wander the dead-end zone of 'classic rock', with a battle cry of "always back, never forward". What's the point of trooping on if you don't throw a few interesting musical shapes?
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
You do realise this is NOT a PF album?concolz wrote:Just when you thought it couldn't get any worse than 'Art Of McCartney' & 'Hollywood Vampires' - it does. Karaoke Alice, prog dinosaur RW, and 'slumming it' orchestra, 'interpret' perpetual dullards Pink Floyd. They're like musical zombies: forever condemned to wander the dead-end zone of 'classic rock', with a battle cry of "always back, never forward". What's the point of trooping on if you don't throw a few interesting musical shapes?
It's a covers/tribute album and nothing at all to do with the band.
I won`t address you other comments about Floyd.. It wouldn`t be polite
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Next thing you know Alice will be singing with Palin and Trump...
Some legends just don't age gracefully...
Some legends just don't age gracefully...
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
ka-ching ( anyone with a sense of humour , would of at least covered Money )
It must be true A_Michael said so
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Ooops....... hard to swallow
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Sounds like alice did his bit in about an hour. Could have done with some double tracked vocals and auto-tuning. As a long time fan I'm forced to admit this is truly awful
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
Yes, I knew it was a covers/'tribute'. It's the third rotten album in a row that Alice has appeared on.Si wrote: You do realise this is NOT a PF album?
It's a covers/tribute album and nothing at all to do with the band.
I won`t address you other comments about Floyd.. It wouldn`t be polite
Re: This Pink Floyd Orchestral Album
BrianRS wrote:Sounds like alice did his bit in about an hour. Could have done with some double tracked vocals and auto-tuning. As a long time fan I'm forced to admit this is truly awful
Has Alice ever used auto-tune? Please nooooo